Seafood Boil Sauce Recipe: Complete Steps To Prepare It!


For all the seafood lovers out there, a boil sauce is a mandatory thing that should always be available when having your sea meat. This is simply because it further enhances the overall flavor of the prepared dish. Well, this is the reason why almost every restaurant serving seafood serves this sauce as a side dip, along with the main dish. Hence, irrespective of whether you are consuming seafood in a restaurant or at home, you will wish to have the sauce every time. Hence, to assist you with this, we decided to list the easiest seafood boil sauce recipe that will not take much of your time. 

In this blog, we will list all the ingredients along with the ways of how to use them for preparing a restaurant-style boil sauce for your seafood. In order to quickly learn this delicious recipe, check out all the ingredients along with the steps listed below. 

Ingredients Required Ingredients Required 

The seafood boil sauce recipe includes basic ingredients that are readily available in your pantry. Hence, let us now have a look at all the ingredients that are required to prepare this delicious sauce. 

Ingredients  Quantity 
Butter (salted or unsalted) 1 Cup 
Olive oil ¼ Cup 
Fish or Chicken Broth ½ Cup 
Chopped Onion  ½ Cup 
Minced Garlic  2 Tablespoons 
Coriander  As per your requirement
Thyme  As per your requirement
Old Bay Seasoning  2 Tablespoons 
Smoked paprika  1 Tablespoon
Garlic Powder ¼ Tablespoon
Black Pepper  ¼ Tablespoon
Red Pepper  ¼ Tablespoon
Brown Sugar  As per your requirement
Lemon (optional) 1 Tablespoon
Mustard Seeds (optional) ¼ Tablespoon

Steps involved in preparing the seafood boil sauce recipe 

Steps involved in preparing the seafood boil sauce recipe 

All the ingredients mentioned in the table given above are very simple. The same goes for the steps for preparing a delicious boil sauce to pour over your cooked seafood. It will hardly take a few minutes for you to prepare the seafood boil sauce. Just make sure you properly read and follow all the steps and instructions listed below. 

Step 1- Let us prepare the base ingredients 

Grab a small pan or skillet and heat it on low flame. Once the skillet is heated, consider adding butter to it. After a few seconds, add olive oil to the same skillet. Mix both of them in a way that they combine with each other. Once your oil and butter are heated, add half a cup of chopped onions to it. Stir the onions and let them cook until they acquire a light golden-brown color. This might approximately take somewhere between four to five minutes. 

Now further, add 2 tablespoons of minced garlic to the cooked golden-brown onions. Now mix the garlic with onions and cook this for two to three minutes. However, we advise you to avoid exceeding the specified time and further overcooking the ingredients. This is because cooking the onion and garlic for more than three minutes will result in a brown mixture. Due to this, your sauce might taste bitter and unpleasant. 

Step 2- Time to add in all the spices and unused ingredients! 

Once you have pleasantly cooked your chopped onions and minced garlic in the mixture of olive oil and butter, it is now time to add in the spices and herbs. Grab all the flavourful spices, including old bay seasoning, garlic powder, red and black pepper powder, along with smoked paprika and mustard seeds. Also, consider adding all the herbs at this point in time. Hence, add the thyme and coriander. However, make sure you add all the ingredients according to the specifications made in the ingredient table. 

Note: Seafood has a salty taste and flavor. Hence, you can skip adding lemon juice. Also, to balance out the flavors, consider adding approximately 1 tablespoon of brown sugar to your seafood boil sauce recipe. 

Step 3- Let’s combine our fish/chicken broth with cooked onions and spices!

Once you have added all the spices, herbs and other ingredients in the desired quantities, consider adding your fish or chicken broth to them. Simply stir the spices so that they combine with cooked onion and garlic. Do not waste/wait any time further cooking them. Simply add your broth to prepare the sauce finally. This mixture further needs to be cooked for around ten to twelve minutes. You can reduce the cooking time to eight minutes by simply covering the pan/skillet with a lid. 

Step 4- Time to enjoy our seafood boil sauce!

After 10 minutes, turn off the flame. You can now transfer the prepared sauce to a bowl and further top it with some coriander. And that’s it! You are all set to enjoy your delicious seafood boil sauce. Additionally, it completely depends on you how you would like to have the sauce. 

  • You can either serve it as a side dip when eating seafood. 
  • Or else, simply pour the boil sauce over the prepared seafood of your choice. 

 Additional details about the seafood boil sauce recipe

Level  Very Easy; anyone can prepare it with the right ingredients and technique
Total time 30 minutes (includes time consumed in preparing the raw ingredients)
Yield  4 servings as a dip, Can be poured on a seafood dish for four people

Common mistakes to avoid when cooking the seafood boil sauce recipe 

Common mistakes to avoid when cooking the seafood boil sauce recipe 

There are certain common mistakes that you should avoid when making a delicious seafood boil sauce at home. These mistakes can ruin your hard work as well as the taste of your boil sauce. Hence, read out the points listed below to ensure that you do not end up making some silly mistakes that can spoil your seafood sauce.

1. Do not use stale ingredients

When preparing your seafood boil sauce, it is advised that you should avoid using stale ingredients. Instead, try to add only fresh ingredients to your overall recipe. Properly wash all the vegetables and herbs and freshly chop them. Also, if possible, try to add freshly ground spices. This will further enhance your boil sauce and give it a fresh taste.

2. Keep a check on the quantity of salt you add

Seafood is generally saltier in comparison to other meats like chicken and mutton. This is clearly because of the saline nature of seawater. Hence, when working on your seafood boil sauce recipe, make sure you add salt in a moderate quantity. Excess salt will make the sauce taste bitter. Also, when seafood will be added to this boil sauce, the overall dish will contain a lot of salt. Hence, the dish will become a disaster. 

Note: This point not only holds for boil sauce recipes but for every seafood dish, dip, and dressing as well.

3. Do not add too much strong spices

Adding strong spices in a large quantity is the biggest mistake you can make when preparing your seafood boil sauce. This is clearly because it will lead to strong spices overpowering the flavors of the other ones. And, as a result, your sauce will most probably contain only strong flavors. 

Hence, to avoid this from happening with your seafood boil sauce recipe, you need to ensure the right amount of spices. Doing this will further lead to a balanced flavor. Additionally, your sauce will also not overpower the taste of seafood which is added to it.

4. Consider eliminating the acidic elements

If you add acidic elements to your seafood boil sauce, they might end up disturbing its overall balance. This is because ingredients like lemon juice and vinegar, when added in excess, can cut down the depth and richness of the prepared sauce. Hence, you should avoid adding them. 

However, if you are someone who likes their sauces to be sour, you can add some lemon juice to it. But make sure that you only add it in a moderate quantity (1 tablespoon in the entire sauce).

5. Maintaining the texture of your boil sauce

You appropriately collected all the ingredients required and also orderly followed the steps involved in making a delicious seafood boil sauce recipe. But, even after doing so, your boil sauce did not turn out as tasty and rich as you were expecting it to be. And now, you are wondering what went wrong. 

Well, this is because while preparing this recipe, you did not focus on its texture. As a result, you could not prepare a boil sauce rich in texture. Well, this is where the mustard seeds come into play. Give a rich and pleasant texture to your seafood boil sauce by adding some mustard seeds to it. Also, make sure you do not overcook the ingredients. This will further help you maintain the consistency of your sauce.

6. Prepare your boil sauce with complete patience

Patience is the key to preparing a finger-licking good boil sauce. Cooking in a rush can lead to undeveloped and underdeveloped flavors. On the other hand, you will also not be able to achieve the desired texture. Additionally, cooking the ingredients on a high flame will directly overwhelm the entire sauce. Hence, we recommend that you never cook your sauce when in a hurry. After all, the cooking time is completely worth waiting for.

7. Prepare your sauce according to different seafood

There are various ways in which boil sauce can be prepared. It is recommended that you follow a seafood boil sauce recipe that is appropriate for different seafoods and goes well with all of them. This is simply because different seafoods have different tastes. For example, there will be a lot of difference in the taste of a crab than that of a lobster. Hence, in this case, you will not prepare several different boil sauces. Instead, prepare a single seafood boil sauce that goes well with every sea meat.

Winding up 

seafood boil sauce recipe

Several websites on the internet contain various different methods to prepare boil sauce for seafood. However, we are sure that our seafood boil sauce recipe is indeed the easiest as well as the tastiest. Also, you can prepare this when you don’t have much time as well. This is simply because it comes together quickly. Hence, we advise you to try out our boil sauce recipe for once. Also, if you do, don’t forget to tell us how it turned out in the comments section. 

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

How much total time will it take to prepare the entire seafood boil sauce recipe?

The recipe of boiling sauce for seafood will not take much time in being prepared. You will have to spare about 30 minutes to make this tasty and delicious seafood boil sauce recipe completely. 

What are the main ingredients required to make the seafood boil sauce?

To prepare your boil sauce, you will only require some basic ingredients that are easily available in the market/pantry. Some of the main ones include fish/chicken broth, a combination of different spices, fresh herbs, and unsalted or salted butter. 

What all seafood variety can I add to my boil sauce?

You can add any meat you feel like adding to your seafood boil sauce. These might include fishes, shrimps, lobsters, crabs, oysters, octopus, etc. Additionally, apart from seafood, you can also add some veg ingredients like potatoes, onions, capsicums, etc, to your seafood sauce. However, the only thing that needs to be considered is to prepare your seafood boil sauce in a way in which it goes well with every seafood and other vegetables as well. 

Is it possible to make veg boil sauce that tastes exactly like seafood boil sauce?

Yes, you can easily make a veg boil sauce that will taste exactly like the seafood one. However, you will have to make a change to the mentioned seafood boil sauce recipe. All you need to do is consider replacing chicken/fish broth with mushroom broth or vegetable broth. Also, you can eliminate using dairy butter and utilize plant-based butter instead, to make a vegan-friendly boil sauce.

Previous articleHow Much Can An Ant Carry- All You Need To Know About It !
Next articleCaring for Your Elder: Home Care or Nursing Home?
Nupur Goyal
Nupur Goyal is a passionate content writer with a total experience of 3 years in the same field. She has written content on diverse niches for many popular websites. She is currently working as a full-time content writer in a reputed digital marketing agency in Delhi. She is really fond of animals, especially dogs. She has a Pitbull named Casper. The only thing she loves besides content writing is playing with dogs, may it be her pet or the strays. Oh, how could we miss including that junk food point. She is a vegetarian and enjoys eating junk food. Chilly Potato with Hot Sause and Cooldrink are her all time favorites.